Become an OC Media MemberSupport independent journalism in the Caucasus:
Join Today
Media logo
Court

Transgender woman appeals to Tbilisi Court to recognise her gender

Transgender woman appeals to Tbilisi Court to recognise her gender
(Facebook)

A Georgian transgender woman is appealing to Tbilisi City Court to have her gender changed in official documents without undergoing sex reassignment surgery.

Nino Bolkvadze from Tbilisi-based rights group the Equality Movement, who is representing the plaintiff, told Liberali Magazine the suit is based on judgements by the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) as well as Georgia’s Constitutional Court.

Three transgender people from Georgia have recently appealed in court on similar grounds. The claims of two transgender people were rejected by all three instances of the judiciary, and have been filed to the ECHR. An appeal by a third transgender person is being examined by the Tbilisi Court of Appeals.

In previous judgements, Georgian courts have ruled that someone’s gender can be changed in official documents only if their reassigned biological sex fully corresponds to their gender, Bolkvadze says. She calls this ‘absurd, as long as it is impossible to have such surgery that will transform a [person’s] biological sex completely’.

On 6 April the ECHR ruled that officially changing one’s gender could not be made conditional on undergoing sex reassignment surgery.

The case, Garçon and Nicot v. France, concerned three French transgender people who had been prevented from changing their sex and forenames on their birth certificates.

The three argued, among other things, that authorities had infringed on their right to respect for private life by making recognition of their gender identity conditional on undergoing an operation which would most likely make them sterile.

‘The Court held, in particular, that making recognition of the sexual identity of transgender persons conditional on undergoing an operation or sterilising treatment to which they did not wish to submit amounted to making the full exercise of one’s right to respect for private life conditional on relinquishing full exercise of the right to respect for one’s physical integrity’, a press release by the ECHR says.

On 10 October Greece’s government passed legislation enabling citizens to determine their own gender identity, amid fierce condemnation from the Greek Orthodox Church and accusations the law would ‘destroy human beings’, the Guardian reported.

‘After two days of highly charged debate, the prime minister, Alexis Tsipras, rallied parliament to endorse policies that would permit people to legally change their gender on all official documents without undergoing sterilisation’, the Guardian writes.

Related Articles

Silence in the courtroom: how one of Chechnya’s last human rights defenders was convicted on drug charges
Chechnya

Silence in the courtroom: how one of Chechnya’s last human rights defenders was convicted on drug charges

Avatar

On 18 March, Chechen human rights defender Oyub Titiyev was sentenced to four years in prison on trumped-up drug charges. He is only the latest victim in Russia’s repressions against civil society in the North Caucasus. ‘Let justice reign!’ reads the banner hanging over the compound of the court house in Shali, Chechnya. The slogan is accompanied by a strict-looking Akhmat Kadyrov, the North Caucasus republic’s former leader. Next to the courthouse, there’s a new business centre (‘Shali-

Court in Ingushetia considers ‘falsified’ vote on Chechnya land deal
Chechen-Ingush Land Deal

Court in Ingushetia considers ‘falsified’ vote on Chechnya land deal

O

A court in the Russian Republic of Ingushetia has begun considering allegations that the parliamentary vote approving a land deal with neighbouring Chechnya was falsified. The controversial deal, which handed around 340 square kilometres (about 9% of Ingushetia’s territory) to Chechnya, was signed by the heads of Ingushetia and Chechnya on 26 September 2018. On 4 October 2018, MPs from Ingushetia’s regional parliament, the People’s Assembly, approved the deal 17-4 in a secret ballot, lead

Trial begins of Chechen rights activist Oyub Titiyev
Chechnya

Trial begins of Chechen rights activist Oyub Titiyev

O

The trial of human rights activist Oyub Titiyev, who heads the Chechen branch of Russian rights group Memorial, kicked off on 18 July in Chechnya’s Shali District Court. Titiyev, who has been in custody since January, is charged with possession of large quantities of cannabis; Titiyev and his defence team reject the accusation, claiming the drugs were planted on him and that the case is politically motivated. Since his arrest in January, Titiyev’s detention has been repeatedly prolonged

South Ossetian court: prosecutors committed ‘procedural violations’ against journalist Mearakishvili
Court

South Ossetian court: prosecutors committed ‘procedural violations’ against journalist Mearakishvili

O

A South Ossetian court has ruled that the local prosecutor’s office committed procedural violations when dismissing a complaint by journalist Tamara Mearakishvili. Mearakishvili told OC Media she had complained regarding the ‘inaction of the general prosecutor’s office’ while investigating her for slander. The ruling United Ossetia party filed a complaint against her for slander in August, after which the prosecutor’s office launched a criminal investigation. Investigators reportedly urged

Most Popular

Editor‘s Picks